Debt Ceiling Extortion

I have no doubt that Congress will raise the debt ceiling. Republicans simply have no choice, but to accept defeat and move on. The United States government pays its bills. Period.

Beyond that though, it’s remarkable how idiotic this argument has become.


Republicans cannot hold the debt ceiling hostage.

In 2011, the last time debt ceiling brinksmanship almost caused an international financial crisis, Republicans were screaming that any debt ceiling increase must be offset by equal spending cuts. The entire goal was to reduce the deficit. While playing chicken with the debt ceiling was irresponsible then, there was at least a bit of logic in terms what Republicans were holding hostage and their ransom demands.

This time though, Republicans are holding the debt ceiling hostage while demanding a one-year delay in Obamacare. There is no connection between the two. Republicans are using the debt ceiling to extort the President. Worse, some Republicans seem ready to breach the debt ceiling if Obama does not back down and agrees to delay his signature legislative achievement. This is where things get absurd.

If we do breach the debt ceiling, it will likely have a significant, long-term negative impact on our debt. Rates on U.S. Treasury notes are lower than any other bond because investors are 100% confident that the U.S. will repay its creditors. The chance that a debtor doesn’t pay its creditor is called credit risk. Companies and countries close to bankruptcy have high credit risks. But the United States is never close to bankruptcy because the dollar is the world’s reserve currency and the U.S. can print its own money. It can always pay back its creditors. That’s why interest rates on Treasury bills are so low. But, if we breach the debt ceiling, that non-zero credit risk rises substantially. Suddenly, it becomes a very real possibility that the U.S. could not pay its creditors. Even if Treasury prioritizes bond payments so it does not technically default on its debts, the act of breaching the debt ceiling will likely shock investors and force them to increase the risk assessment of Treasury notes. That means considerably higher-interest rates for the U.S. in the long-term and thus higher interest payments.

In 2011, J.P. Morgan estimated that rates on Treasury Bills would rise 50 basis points if we breached the debt ceiling. They predicted that it in the long-term, that would add $75 billion per year to the deficit.  Compare that to the sequester, which was the result of the 2011 debt ceiling deal. It cut spending by $1.1 trillion over 10 years. Breaching the debt ceiling would effectively undo nearly three-quarters of those cuts in the form of increased interest payments.

So, in 2011, Republicans were so concerned about the deficit that they took the debt ceiling hostage to extract $1.1 trillion in spending cuts.
Now, Republicans are so concerned about Obamacare that they’ve taken the debt ceiling hostage and risked adding $750 billion to our long-term debt.

If Republicans were so worried our long-term debt two years ago, why are they willing to undo most of those spending cuts this time? Does that seem like Republicans actually care about our debt and are using the debt ceiling as a principle to get our fiscal house under control? Or does it seem more like an irresponsible, reckless party risking a global financial collapse in order to extort the President?

That’s why President Obama and Senate Democrats cannot and will not negotiate on the debt ceiling. There is nothing principled about Republican arguments here. The debt ceiling is simply a mechanism to hold the President hostage and force his hand. That’s unacceptable. Enough with debt-ceiling histrionics. Our democracy does not work that way.


7 thoughts on “Debt Ceiling Extortion

  1. Pingback: Webanews

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s